Participants. Dan Koch, moderator; Myron Penner; Sarah Lane Ritchie; Matthew David Segall. See https://theologybeer.camp/2026speakers for bios.
Transcript:
Dan: If you’re going to be making some meaning you’ve got to be comfortable first [adjusts chair].
Matt: I disagree.
Dan: Yeah, you know what? It is not really existential of me to say that you need to be comfortable first. That’s just me feeling late stage capitalism.
Matt: I think so.
Myron: Thanks for coming everybody!
Dan: My name is Dan Koch. I’m here with three lovely philosophers: Sarah Lane Ritchie, Myron Penner, and Matt Segall.
We were talking about the science of meaning, meaning making, disenchantment, and misenchantment. What we’re going to try to do here is explain terms and make this understandable to people without graduate degrees.
I’ll make meaning making really practical up front. I’m a psychologist in private clinical practice, and I specialize in clients who have undergone religious change. Every single client who has undergone religious change has some work to do around meaning making. What did it mean that I was in that group? What does it mean that I’m not in that group? How do I make sense of this? How can I turn it into some sort of coherent story?
If you’re wondering how to think about this practically, you can start there. If things change in your life, you need a way to narrate it. You need a way to make meaning and sense out of it internally. Of course, often we make that meaning together as well. It’s not only an individual activity.
We’re starting with the science of meaning. Myron, you have a scientific way of understanding how we can break this down. You’re a particularly science-grounded and psychology-grounded philosopher. You’ve got your three components of meaning making. Let’s hear you explain them.
Myron: Do we want to introduce ourselves?
Dan: Yes. I didn’t prep an intro paragraph. You’re all philosophers in my mind. [Unclear banter.] This is going well.
Myron: I just wanted the opportunity to say, “Hey, thanks for coming, everybody.” I’m Myron. I’m a Professor of Philosophy at Trinity Western University. It’s my third year at camp, and it’s good to see lots of familiar faces and some new ones. I really appreciate you all coming to this session.
Sarah: Hi, I’m Sarah Lane Ritchie. My official background is in science and religion, which is a thing—the intersection of theological studies and psychology, or whatever other things you want to engage. Now I’m at the John Templeton Foundation, and most of my portfolio right now is meaning making, which is, I’m guessing, part of the reason I’m talking about it.
Matt: Matt Segall. I’m a process philosopher. I teach graduate students at the California Institute of Integral Studies in San Francisco, and I’m the director of the Process and Science Network at the Center for Process Studies.
I think across disciplines. Sometimes I call myself a transdisciplinary researcher, which is basically a dilettante who’s interested in everything. My home base, though, is process philosophy. That’s how I pay the bills—some of them.
Myron: Because that’s where the money is.
Matt: Yeah. I’m excited to get into this with you all.
Dan: Thank you for keeping me on track. Let’s start, Myron. You’ve put some stuff together about how to think about meaning and how we go about making meaning.
Myron: When we talked about how to structure this panel and what each of us could bring relative to our own areas of interest, we decided I would start by presenting how psychologists in the last few decades have come to converge on a model for understanding meaning making.
I’m going to do three things very briefly: spend a few minutes talking about this psychological account of meaning making; give what I think is a nice evolutionary context for why we evolved these cognitive capacities that, when you put them together, give us a sense of meaning in the world; and end with a little talk about spirituality and meaning.
One of the three main components psychologists refer to is this very intuitive idea that something is meaningful to us when it helps us make sense of things. Something is meaningful when it has a degree of fit with things we already think are true, when it explains things, or when it fills gaps in our understanding of the world. Sometimes something strikes us as meaningful in this coherence kind of way when it sheds new light on existing frameworks and helps us understand how things make sense.
I don’t know how many of you were at the opening session last night, but hearing Cornel West describe certain responses to injustice as a manifestation of cowardice that is both ancient and pervasive—a light turned on for me. It was meaningful in this sense-making way. As he said it, you could see heads nodding in the room, this palpable “Huh.” That’s a meaningful moment in this idea of making sense of our world.
Dan: It makes me think of the scene in Django Unchained, Jonah Hill’s little cameo, where they’re getting together to form a lynch mob, but they’re arguing about the hoods. The eyeholes aren’t cut in the right place to see, but they also don’t want anyone to see their faces because they’re cowards. It’s played for laughs, but there’s such a dark sadness under that. Cowardice is a good term for what’s being described there.
Myron: Right. It’s an explanation for lots of behavior we see. When it’s pointed out, it sheds light on something we’re experiencing in a way that makes sense.
In addition to sense making, psychologists often talk about things being meaningful when they let you know how and in what ways you matter. Something is experienced as significant in and of itself, but also gives you an understanding of how you personally matter and to whom you matter. Not necessarily that you’re better than someone else, but a sense of how you fit within a broader social network of relationships in ways that are good for you.
Something is meaningful when it helps us make sense of things, gives us a sense of our own significance, and shows us how we matter and to whom we matter. Many of you are having meaningful moments here at Beer Camp when you receive warm greetings from old and new friends. Those can be very meaningful moments in this way.
The third component is that something is meaningful when it helps orient us toward goals. It identifies goals and purposes deemed worthy, and shows how we are on a journey toward pursuing them. Some of you are runners and have set a goal to qualify for the Boston Marathon. That’s a very daunting goal for some people. To work toward it is to pursue a meaning-making activity.
Trying to live according to your values—taking a step back and identifying the values you’re trying to pursue—is to pursue a life of meaning. I would dare say that receiving joyful calls to action in times of catastrophe is also to orient yourself toward a meaningful goal.
If we think about meaning as composed of things that help us make sense of our world, identify how and to whom we matter, and orient us toward a sense of purpose, we can see exactly why there’s a strong correlation between religious systems and meaning. Religion provides an interpretive framework for your life. It lets you know how and in what ways you matter, and it orients your life according to a particular purpose.
There are strong correlations in psychological research between religiosity—people engaging in religious practices—and their own sense of meaning. Not necessarily happiness. Religion doesn’t necessarily make you happy, but it does give you a sense of meaning. The other thing religion has as part of its secret sauce is that it generally gives you a bit more ease about contemplating your own mortality. It mitigates death anxiety.
To put this in an evolutionary perspective, interpreting our world in a way that helps us make sense of our environment has strong adaptive value. We see this in other animals, actually. Other animals have models for cause and effect in their world. It helps them acquire tools to navigate their environment as they think about how different causes have different effects.
We don’t like it—and we see this in other primates—when things violate our expectations or don’t make sense to us. We’ve all got strategies to get rid of that uncomfortable feeling. This desire for things to cohere and make sense has its own adaptive benefit.
Finding significance, finding out to whom you matter and how you fit in a social network, also has adaptive value. We have an evolutionary history of group living. When you live in groups, it’s important to know where you fit in the hierarchy, who has the power, and who has the networks. We see this in humans and other primate groups.
Attributing purpose to things also seems to have adaptive benefits. It’s an extension of our causal reasoning. Attributing purpose to people’s actions helps us navigate social space and explain other people’s behavior: “So-and-so did something because they wanted to achieve some purpose.” This propensity to find purpose is part of our evolutionary backstory.
When you put it all together, when something contributes to our sense of coherence, significance, and purpose, it’s recruiting these deeply embedded and adaptive cognitive processes. Maybe we’ll stop there and see how you want to navigate things from here.
Dan: I like how you laid out the way religion and religiosity meet those needs for meaning. I’d also like to add a quick layer: spirituality without a lot of doctrinal or theological content—a lot of cognitive content—can also meet all three needs.
I’m drawing on Lisa Miller’s work and her definition of spirituality as connection to a higher power that is loving and guiding. By that, she can mean something like, “The way the birds lined up on a canoeing trip helped me see that I’m part of something.” It can be very minimal.
Really briefly: coherence. If there’s a higher power, that higher power has some kind of control. At least things make sense from the perspective of that higher power, even if they don’t always make sense to me.
Significance: through my connection to that loving, guiding higher power, I participate in something. If I’m loved, that tells me I’m valuable enough.
Purpose: it’s loving and guiding. The guiding of that higher power, even if it’s fairly vague or has few bullet points, gives me some sort of roadmap for moving forward.
We’re all on a continuum here at camp in how much doctrinal specificity we give to our faith, if we have it. The stuff we’re talking about is applicable to that whole continuum. Sarah or Matt, anything Myron said that sends you in a fun direction?
Sarah: I think we may have discussed this earlier in the year, but when I hear people talk about these different ways of understanding meaning, we have the sense-making part, which is obvious to a lot of us. I read a book and it means something. The words mean something in my head.
For most of us, when we use the word “meaning” in this context, we’re talking about something much more existential. We’re talking about this sense of mattering. The tension that I live in—I don’t know if I enjoy living in it—is that a lot of the work I do is experiential, phenomenological, first-person.
Most of us in this room probably have the experience, even daily, of knowing that we matter to a lot of people, to different causes, to communities. I know I matter to my children. But if we’re only dealing in sense making and mattering, it feels like something is lost when we say, “I feel like I’m living a meaningful life.”
If I can matter to someone else but also not feel a sense of X, Y, or Z—we can talk about what those characteristics might be—it feels like something is lost in the definition. I’m wondering if you have anything you’d want to say about that.
Myron: Mattering is said in many ways, right? From a more existential approach to meaning, it’s one thing to matter to someone because you have something they need. There’s a very transactional sense in which you matter, and that might not contribute to your sense of meaning at all.
Knowing someone depends on you for things, or looks to you to provide something you may not even want to provide or get a sense of your own significance from providing—that’s not the kind of mattering that’s really going to contribute to a sense of meaning.
But being known in a certain way, in a relationship where someone sees you and knows you, and not just in spite of that but as a result of that, you matter to them—that’s the meaningful sense of mattering we’re trying to talk about. It’s not necessarily a transactional “Oh, I matter” in this less existentially significant way. It’s at a deep, deep level. But you’re right: a lot of that doesn’t get referenced when we talk about mattering.
Matt: I want to get to what you laid out about evolution and why meaning might be adaptive. But first, this question Sarah raises—“Do I matter?”—really means, “Who do I matter to?” Not just as a means to their ends, but as an end in myself, as intrinsically valuable.
But It’s through relationships that we make meaning. We inherit most of our meaning from the communities we’re born into. Some people, because of discomfort in their communities of birth, lose that sense of meaning they got just from being embedded. Then they have to make meaning for themselves for the first time. They have to create new meaning. Without the discomfort of not fitting into the community of your birth, I don’t know that many people end up needing to make their own meaning.
Philosophers are kind of weird in that—well, I’ll speak for myself—I do get a lot of meaning from reading Process and Reality. Most people don’t need a worked-out systematic metaphysics to make meaning. They get meaning from having families, friends, and communities. It seems to me that most nihilists are loners.
Regarding evolution, a lot depends on what we mean by evolution. I think evolution is a fact. But if evolution is just differential selection of random mutations, I think the fact that any animal became conscious, and therefore needed to make meaning, is profoundly maladaptive. It would be much better if we were just machines that made copies of ourselves without worrying about, “Who do I matter to? Is there a God?” That’s getting in the way of that kind of evolutionary process.
Dan: And the despair stuff too—deaths of despair, a crisis of meaning, right?
Matt: All these things associated with consciousness of meaning and its loss seem very maladaptive. But the good news is that evolution is not just random mutation and differential survival through natural selection. Consciousness has been part of the process, I would say, at least since the first cells.
That means it’s not just about survival. It’s about: How do I thrive as an organism? How do I enrich my experience as an organism? How do I seek out new forms of relationship to make new kinds of meaning that bring forth new worlds? That’s been going on since at least the dawn of life, I would say. Evolution is more than a mechanistic process.
Dan: To get a little existential and practical at the same time, I do existential therapy with my religious-change clients. The reason we use the term “existential crisis,” even in the popular understanding, is that it typically takes a crisis, as Matt’s saying, to be forced to face certain questions. They’re so uncomfortable to ask, all other things being equal. They use so much bandwidth. They threaten the bedrock of some of our primary relationships, including family and marriage. It’s just not pleasant to go through.
We tend not to opt in, except maybe some nihilistic loners. There might be some self-selection going on there.
You have some sort of crisis. I’ll use faith change as the primary one I deal with. What the existential work ends up addressing is, in fact, meaning. I thought I’d do a quick thumbnail and see if that brings up anything for you guys.
When the bricks have fallen on the house, or the church, or whatever your metaphor is, you have to look inward. You gestured at this earlier, Matt: you’re given a story of meaning and significance as part of the group you’re raised in. If you leave, if you change, if you’re not in that group anymore, that story doesn’t work.
In deconstruction spaces, people say, “The genie doesn’t go back in the bottle.” You can’t go back to believing inerrancy. Very few people do, probably through great psychological exertion and perhaps other things. Mostly, you can’t. You’re now on the other side of some wall, and you’ve got to figure out what you’re doing there. You have to look inward.
We do a lot of work identifying your deepest values. What actually matters to you, potentially separate from what you were taught should matter to you? Sometimes there’s great overlap. People find things in the life and teachings of Jesus and say, “No, wholeheartedly, I’m in on that.” Okay, great.
Through that broader process, you become more of a participant in the meaning. It costs you something because you don’t have that certainty, that felt sense that things are set in concrete, which you might have had growing up. But you gain participation.
Participation and collaboration around the meaning of your own life have something to say here. If you need coherence, you’ve got to figure out a way to tell the story. It’s pretty clear how that can lead to feeling significant, because you’re more of an author of something. Purpose becomes partly self-made or collaborated on, as opposed to handed down to you.
Handed-down purpose can work perfectly well. Think about the military or most religious systems. There’s nothing inherently wrong with it. But there’s something robust and long-lasting about collaborated-on, internally found, rebuilt purpose. There’s a buy-in that usually comes part and parcel with the process.
Myron: You’ve pointed out a reason it’s so hard for people who leave conservative religious spaces to get there. They’ve been socialized and theologized in a context that has told them they don’t have permission to write their own story. They don’t have the authority to make sense of their own lives or to be sufficiently significant in the writing of that story. It takes a long time to get to that point.
Sarah: What’s coming up for me is a question of agency. A lot of people who have undergone religious change will say very quickly, “I would love not to desire, long for, or struggle with all of these things. The fact is, my developmental psychology is just that. I grew up with a very particular set of beliefs, longings, hopes, dreams, purposes, and a worldview. I can no longer cognitively assent to it—there are other ways you might leave a religion, but let’s just say cognitively. I can’t buy into that world anymore, but I kind of wish I could.”
Then you’re in this transition period. You’re both talking about writing your own story. Something I’ve thought about before is: Is it a fiction or a nonfiction story? We all know the story we’d like to experience as real, as true. I could easily write a quick story I’d sign up for in a second. But knowing the story we want to be true about our lives is different from what’s experienced as psychologically possible, metaphysically true, scientifically accurate.
There’s a tension between a willingness and desire to write your own story in a meaning crisis and what is possible for you at a given moment, or ever. That edge is where a lot of people are. I’m not always convinced a lot of people ever leave that spot, and maybe that’s okay. That might be fine. But it’s a different way of experiencing your own sense of identity and meaning.
Dan: People don’t leave what spot?
Sarah: You might never leave the spot of—and I’m not proclaiming this true for everybody—but it’s entirely possible to be a good-faith, intelligent, rational actor who is spiritually sensitive and all of these things, and never find yourself experiencing the narrative you’re trying to write as satisfying, salient, or powerful, because you’re not experiencing it as real.
Dan: I was talking about this with a client the other day—
Myron: We want names.
Dan: I used the metaphor of somebody who has gotten clean from opioids. Part of the deal is that you’re basically agreeing never to have a certain kind of peak experience again. It’s not that you think you should have it again. You know you shouldn’t, because the other costs are too great. It’s not worth it.
If you really want to stay clean from opioids, from an existential perspective we would say a big part of that will be truly accepting that this is the cost. You experienced something at the peak of what the human brain can do, and you were able to get it [unclear]. That’s not going to happen anymore.
Sarah: I would push back on that, because this is really important. It’s not just a semantic detail. There are a couple of addiction scientists I’ve interacted with over the last few years. I had a psychiatrist tell me at a conference last year, “No, the goal is not just to resign yourself to being miserable and suffering for the rest of your life.”
Dan: I know, I know—
Sarah: They’ll say the goal is to let go of the particular manifestation and object of that desire and need for the big experience. Accept that you’re a person who needs a certain sort of experience. It doesn’t have to be a peak experience; it could be a sense of purpose or an immortal afterlife, or all these things.
The goal is to get to a point where you experience that peak experience, peace, connectedness, or purpose in a way that feels as real—or ideally more real—than the thing in which you used to experience it.
The hard thing is that sometimes it takes a while to figure out what that will be. It also takes a while because you have to—I hate the term “rewire your brain,” but you’re working with a biological, psychological organism. You need to give yourself a chance to immerse yourself in contexts and structures most likely to give you the thing that will be most satisfying.
Dan: I agree with all of that. I’m not saying the whole thing is limited to accepting that you won’t have the same high again. But it is part of it. If you’re willing to sign up for a different set of peak experiences, they’re not just going to be at your command. That’s the thing about drugs: you can make it happen right now. In part, that speed and feedback make them psychologically addictive.
I’m totally with you. To bring it back into religious change, it’s a whole package deal. One thing I’ve found helpful about existential psychology is the absolute commitment to there being no free lunch. There’s no little thing you can do that has no other cost.
Spirituality and faith are energizing in a way that can feel like free energy. But at a minimum, at a biological level, you need to rest afterward. If you’re really happy for a few days, you’re going to have a day where you’re kind of down. There are certain laws of this: it has to get paid back. That’s part of the physical world we live in.
With these clients, we can make a list: What does it cost you? What are the actual costs of being out of that group? Certainty, absolute membership in a group, existential fear being entirely subsumed within it—those were real benefits you experienced.
And what were the costs? “I couldn’t be friends with my best friend because they’re gay. I could never date the kind of people I wanted to date.” You list all these things. It’s a trade-off. Is this going to be a better set of trade-offs that you can make more realistic, ongoing, and healthy?
In the drug example, you’re trading a handful of repeatable, plannable peak experiences for something less obvious but more textured, something that will surprise you in ways where it’s not only after you do the drug that you feel good. It’s a whole package you’re trading for.
Matt: You brought up the term “participation” earlier, which I wanted to go back to.
Dan: No surprise the process philosopher wants to talk about participation.
Matt: Once you’ve lost the ready-made meaning of your community of origin, which you took to be certain, and discovered that there are many other viable options—and that, had you been born in another community, maybe that would have been your certainty—you get into this dilemma: “If it’s not ready-made meaning, it must be made-up meaning.” This fiction–nonfiction thing.
A synonym for participation would be co-creation. It’s not certainty anymore. You can’t have certain meaning. But you can have a kind of meaning that is co-created, not just with other human beings who are now part of your community of choice. You also co-create meaning with the whole history of life on Earth. You co-create meaning with your physiology, what you eat, the drugs you do or don’t do. These all become characters, participants in your meaning-making project.
There’s no more certainty. But rather than having a solid ground to stand on, you discover a flow state that can be quite enriching.
The other thing about spirituality: spiritual-but-not-religious people have left religion. Someone said to me the other day, “Religion binds you, and spirituality frees you.” I think that’s true, but the problem is you can get so free that you end up making your own meaning up. It’s fictional. It’s good for you, but nobody else really buys into it.
Sometimes we need to feel bound to the others we’re co-creating with for our meaning to have gravity and heft, to be more than just a fleeting fantasy.
Sarah: I have a question for all three of you. It could just be yes or no, or whatever the one word is.
Dan: Good luck.
Sarah: This is something I’ve been mulling over for quite a while: Is a meaningful life in the eye of the beholder?
Let’s say that by any objective external standard, definition, or criteria—and there are whole research projects on the components of a meaningful life—you’re Mother Teresa, but you’re also zenned out all the time in a transcendent state. You have your meditation practice down. By any objective measure, you’re living a meaningful life. You’ve got a great community, a wonderful family, meaningful relationships, all these things. But you experience your life as meaningless.
Is that possible? Are those mutually exclusive? You’re objectively living a life everyone around you would describe as meaningful, but you don’t experience it as meaningful, at least not consistently.
If so, my hypothesis is that the first-person experience of a life of meaning is often less about meaning in the way we’re talking about it and much more about cognate concepts and experiences—related, but not the same. Hope, absorption, losing yourself—there’s a Hillsong song about “the art of losing myself.” It could be hope, losing track of time, transcendence, peace, excitement.
There are so many related experiences that get clumped together, appropriately, in one’s self-assessment of whether one’s life is meaningful. Which is more important? Is a meaningful life in the eye of the beholder, or is it external metrics, and you’re just along for the ride?
Matt: It sounds like you’re describing an analytic philosopher: someone who actually is leading a meaningful life, but when they think intellectually about meaning…
Sarah: Once you start getting into it, you find very quickly that the question we’re asking—“What is the science of meaning, of a meaningful life?”—is not a question that’s been asked, or even been able to be asked, by a lot of cultures, in a lot of places, across a lot of periods of time.
In some ways, it’s a very maladaptive question even to ask: “What is meaning, and how do I get it?” As soon as you start analyzing it and trying to pursue it and curate your life so it’s meaningful, you’ve almost lost the plot.
But that doesn’t solve the problem. We are in this space, this culture, this intellectual or spiritual tradition. I do experience myself as having meaning or not having meaning. What do you do about it, even if you’ve acknowledged that your narrative or worldview is perhaps not the correct one? You still are who you are and where you are.
Matt: Can I connect meaning and truth? We’re talking about the science of meaning. I hear we’re in a wisdom famine, a meaning crisis. We’re also in a post-truth, post-fact era. Truth and meaning are deeply wed. We can’t have one without the other.
Sarah: It has to feel true.
Matt: The nihilist, the materialist, would say, “I’m into truth, and meaning is subjective,” or whatever. Whitehead says the interest in scientific truth is a variant form of religious interest. Why is truth important? It’s meaningful to us. That’s why.
Dan: I’ll hazard a quick answer, and then, Myron, you can answer. Meaning, the way I work with it psychologically, is by definition in the eye of the beholder—the type of meaning we’re talking about. I don’t think it can be another way. It’s definitional.
As to your example of a life that looks meaningful but someone experiences as unmeaningful, I appreciate you bringing in anthropology. There might be entire populations that don’t even have a word in their language for what we mean by “meaning.” Those people probably experience meaningful lives. We would certainly guess that.
There’s a strong correlation, but it’s not one-to-one. If someone has robust community, is relatively physically well, has interests, and has a job they enjoy, then in 96 out of 100 cases they’ll describe their lives as meaningful. But not everybody, because people are weird and different. There’s variety.
Occasionally there will be a brain that works in such a way that they don’t consider that meaningful. Maybe with therapy and tough work they can figure out what they’re missing. For some, maybe they never will. Maybe if they lived a thousand years they might, and maybe some wouldn’t. Yes, it’s possible. It’s probably not that common. There’s a strong correlation, but that’s not everything.
Myron: I think meaning is like pain. In certain philosophical discussions, people ask: If you think you’re in pain, could you be mistaken? I don’t think you can. If it seems to you that you’re in pain, you’re in pain.
You might be mistaken about what’s causing your pain or about the process. There’s lots of research on phantom pain: people who’ve lost limbs but still feel like their arm hurts when they don’t have an arm. They’re still in pain. They might just be inaccurate about where it’s coming from.
If you feel that something is meaningful—if it contributes to the sense of significance, purpose, and coherence we’re talking about—then it is meaningful. Conversely, even though you’re hitting all these metrics and someone from the outside might say you have an objectively meaningful life, if it doesn’t feel that way on the inside, it’s not.
On the evolutionary side, the question is: Does being the sort of animal that can consciously reflect on its own death and mortality—one cognitive anthropologist calls us “the ape that will jump,” the ape that will consider its own despair—does that seem maladaptive? By itself it might, but it’s hard to have inventories like that.
From a 50,000-foot evolutionary perspective, the secret of our success as a species is our capacity for cognitive processes that develop cumulative culture. We share knowledge so we can create tools, cooking strategies, and foraging strategies and share them across generations. If a byproduct of having brains like that is conscious experience, it’s going to be a trade-off.
There might be evolutionary downsides to being conscious beings, but if you look at the whole totality, we’ve done okay as a species from a competition standpoint. I wouldn’t necessarily say consciousness is maladaptive.
Dan: There’s maladaptive at the group level and at the individual level. For some people, all those capacities may make it harder to live their lives, but that doesn’t mean it hurts the species’ propagation. Maybe that’s a way to square it.
Matt: It depends on what we mean by evolution. If making more copies of yourself is the name of the game, bacteria won. If that’s all evolution is about, what’s being optimized for, bacteria won billions of years ago. Humans seem on pace to go extinct pretty soon, most likely. Dinosaurs were around way longer than us. Maybe it’s too soon to say humans are so successful.
My larger point is that whether consciousness is maladaptive depends on what we mean by evolution. If it only came online when the fifty-billionth neuron connected in the right way, versus having been there in germ at least from the first cell, that’s a different picture of evolution.
Dan: I have a feeling we’re going to get some really good audience questions. I’d like to reserve this last half hour for them. You can address them to one of us or to the group. Try to keep it short. I’ll repeat the question into the microphone so it’s there for people listening later.
Audience questions
Audience member: As I’m listening, I hear language and concepts verging on happiness, well-being, and flourishing research, whether it’s Aristotelian, positive psychology, or capabilities approaches. I’m less familiar with the meaning-making sciences. What’s the distinction between meaning making and flourishing? Why talk about meaning making? What’s the importance of this science versus those other sciences?
Dan: There’s a lot of overlap between meaning making, human flourishing, and happiness. Why focus on meaning? Isn’t there an interesting story from the research?
Myron: A real-life story, or research?
Sarah: I’ve heard Dylan, a colleague, describe a move among happiness and flourishing researchers toward recognizing, “Actually, I think we were trying to get at meaning.” Now, that’s meaningfulness, which is distinct from the process of meaning making, but there’s an overlap. I don’t know if you guys have anything to add.
Myron: It’s psychological science, so there’s always a question when people create scales and measures, collect data, and point out effect sizes between different concepts: What exactly are we measuring? We have to hold these things with an open hand.
Generally, research on subjective well-being involves things like: How happy are you? How well do you think your life is going? When researching people’s sense of meaning or the meaningfulness of their lives, it’s a different set of things they’re collecting.
What they seem to find is that happiness is much more variable. Happiness can fluctuate up and down, and what they’re measuring is contingent on a variety of other factors. Meaning structures tend to be more stable and resilient over time, and they correlate with different things.
It was a throwaway comment earlier, but religiosity is a much stronger predictor of a sense of meaning than of happiness. I’m part of a research project with a colleague at my university and researchers from UBC and elsewhere. We’re looking at this massive, 23-country data set, the Global Flourishing Survey, with over 200,000 participants worldwide. They’ve researched people’s spiritual practices, religious practices, sense of meaning, well-being, and other things, then correlated those with GDP and other economic factors.
Our research question is: For whom, and in what circumstances, does religiosity correlate with meaning and well-being? We’re getting interesting results, but they do come apart. Religion is much more a predictor of meaning.
The social-scientific answer is that these things come apart in different ways. There’s still utility in treating them as different constructs and analyzing them that way.
Dan: As a clinician, if I could pick only one thing for my client, I’d take meaning over happiness. It’s probably for similar reasons: that feels more robust, likelier to last.
Unidentified panelist: Like process philosophy—that’s where the money is.
Dan: I want happiness. I want at least a certain amount of happiness and lack of depression for my clients. But meaning is a stronger life raft when times are tough. It’s probably less externally related. There’s a different robustness from a clinical perspective.
Sarah: In a recent-history context, all four of us are connected around the umbrella term of meaning making that came out of work [network name unclear] at the John Templeton Foundation has been doing over the last five years or so. We connected a long time ago, but we’re all in one way or another part of this initiative I was doing called the Spiritual Yearning Research Initiative, focused on the spiritual-but-not-religious population.
Meaning making—and I’ll call it an umbrella term; I’m not convinced it’s divorced from happiness. I think happiness gets a bad rap, which I can talk about later. But the way I and the scholars I work with have been using “meaning making” in a research context is to get at the goods traditionally associated with religion that we might want to pull apart from that religious packaging for research purposes, looking at the spiritual-but-not-religious population and religious change.
What sorts of research projects across disciplines are going to feed into something that’s not happiness, not necessarily global flourishing—Templeton also funded a lot of that work—but gets at salience and thriving in a way that doesn’t discount the experiential, first-person, existential reality of a person’s life? We’ve been looking at particular manifestations of that.
Audience member: You said that one of the downsides of meaning making is that it can feel made up, and that makes it harder to make it stick. Have you found more success in trying to get back to a point where you don’t have to think that you’re making it up? Or is it, “Sorry, the existential crisis is like the puberty stage of becoming an adult, and you have to do that now”?
Sarah: My partner is a philosopher—[description unclear]. I’m not going to say his name, because we have a recurring debate in our household about whether death anxiety is an immature emotional reaction or just something that’s there and you can’t really change.
I’m on the side of: if you have death anxiety and genuinely dread dying—which I think is totally rational, by the way—that’s a reality. He would say, “No, it’s immature and irrational. You need to go about creating the life you want.” I think there are biological and psychological realities that don’t give you total access to whatever experience you want to have.
What I will say, from the research we’ve been doing—or the researchers have been doing—on meaning making is that there seems to be some benefit to putting yourself in the right places and settings, doing certain things with your body and other people as parts of your day, your week, and your life.
There are habits, practices, spiritual technologies—things you can do that won’t immediately guarantee something you might call meaning, but are more likely to structure your life so that meaning becomes something you find is just there, as ambience, even when you’re miserable.
Any parents in the room? You can have some real bad days with your kids. You’re on two hours of sleep, like I am right now. Everything is going badly. You’re unable to invest in your career anymore, or something. But then you step back and say, “I’m miserable today”—not today, but in general, one can say that—“but over the last six months, a year, or two years, I have to say I am experiencing my life as meaningful.”
It’s not “fake it till you make it.” It’s structurally allowing yourself to build a life that supports a scaffolding for meaning.
Matt: One way we can make the meanings we make more robust is to come into shared commitment with others around the nature of those meanings. This is the community element, but community around the making of meaning, so we begin to share intentions and are bound to others.
That might seem like it’s taking away your freedom. But there’s always going to be a trade-off, because now you’re committed to something larger than yourself. When you become part of something larger than yourself, that might be where this flow-state thing comes online. You’re no longer just your little isolated self. You belong to a larger body, in a way.
Myron: I liked Cornel West’s reference to Beckett’s term “perhaps.” When you find something meaningful, the absurdity questions say, “But is it really meaningful? Am I just making it up?” What if we took a posture of, “Perhaps there’s something meaningful that we’ve found in the universe, and I’m just going to inhabit that space”?
Audience member: As we think about where we’re going with AI and how we’re becoming more individualized, I see more people turning to AI as their friend, therapist, or pastor. What are your thoughts?
Dan: I expect the three of them are going to be very anti, and I’ll be very pro.
Unidentified panelist: I take a middle position on AI, which satisfies no one.
Sarah: I don’t have a lot of thoughts on that. There are a lot of things to be concerned about with AI. Personally, I’m not concerned about preserving some fundamental distinction between artificial intelligence and human intelligence. I’m not concerned about preserving anything distinctive about humanity. I think there are other things to worry about.
There’s a way of looking at the potential future possibilities around AI and humans, when it comes to meaning, relationships, and transformative experiences, such that you can imagine a world in which artificial intelligence allows humans to experience something they probably wouldn’t have had within their grasp. I’m talking spiritually, experientially, relationally, in terms of meaning—something they might not have had access to before.
I don’t know how much money I’d bet on that, but there’s a curious approach.
Dan: It’ll be a trade-off. It won’t be a free lunch, nor will it be all catastrophe. That’s my prediction, based in existential psychology.
Matt: I’m not anti-AI. When people go to it to ask therapeutic, religious, or personal questions, or for advice—“I’m in an argument with my partner. They said this, and I said this. Who’s right?”—people are getting this—
Myron: You can train them to give you the right response.
Matt: Of course. “My AI said this.” “Well, mine said this.”
I just wrote a book on this because people don’t stop asking me, “What do you think about AI? Is it good? Is it bad?” I was inspired to write a book because of Pope Leo’s encyclical about this question. I really agree with a lot of what he says there.
There’s a real risk of caring more about Claude’s well-being than about the Filipino people doing the labeling, or the children doing the mining that makes this technology possible. Let’s not lose our minds here, because we’re really at risk of losing our minds. We’re so lonely that we’re projecting consciousness onto chatbots.
They’re very sophisticated—not just chatbots, I know. Very sophisticated, amazing technology. But they’re not conscious. They don’t have feelings.
Sarah: That’s entirely arguable. We don’t have to get into that, but—
Matt: [Beginning of response unclear.] The inventor of functionalism, Hilary Putnam, later rejected it, and the computer engineers just kept going with it. That’s the only basis I can see for saying they’re emotional or whatever.
I think of them as mirrors. You don’t want to spend all your time in front of the mirror making sure your hair looks just right. They can reflect back our own thinking and help us make sure our thoughts are presentable. But the whole point of thinking is to be in communication with other thinkers. There’s no thinking happening in a microchip.
Myron: The question of whether AI will contribute to meaning or undermine it as it becomes more pervasive is interesting. I’ll reference a comment I heard Kutter Callaway make in a session this morning, citing research about how people have different attitudes toward AI generationally.
If you’re thirty and above, you see AI as an executive assistant or research tool, an answer person. If you’re younger, you’re inclined to treat these bots as companions. It’ll be interesting to see, with kids just starting to become conversant with AI in their own interface with technology, both what the technology will look like ten years from now and what their relationship to it will be. That story is yet to be written.
Dan: Black shirt.
Audience member: I’d like to go back to the title of the talk and concentrate on the end: “in a disenchanted world.” Is there a connection between meaning making and enchantment or disenchantment? There’s talk about reenchantment, but “re” means going back. Maybe we need to talk about post- or trans-enchantment as something different. Maybe more for Matt: Is there something in Whitehead’s concept of aesthetics that can be part of that process?
Another questioner: Can I add another word: nostalgia?
Matt: I don’t think we’ve ever been disenchanted. Maybe a very small slice of the intelligentsia became disenchanted at some point. But the whole idea that a large language model could be conscious is a great example of the power of enchantment.
I like the term “misenchantment.” We’ve not become disenchanted in the modern period. We’ve become misenchanted with technology, celebrity, money, and all these surrogate forms of divinity, ultimately.
Even people who take science seriously also believe in an immortal soul, think nature has intrinsic beauty, and once in a while check their horoscope because, who knows, it might be valuable at some level. I just don’t know when we ever actually became disenchanted. Capitalism leads us to mechanize the natural world—so does communism, actually—but we still find other forms of enchantment.
Dan: I have an example, though. To repeat the question—and I did have a question I didn’t get to, to give myself a shred of credit—does disenchantment equal a meaning crisis, or can we disentangle these terms?
I can’t remember who told me this. It might have been our own Tony Jones or somebody else. Someone said they think of disenchantment this way: If you got cancer, you would have gone to a priest to pray for you, or a shaman to do some ritual. Now you go to an oncologist.
That’s true for basically 98 percent of people. There’s a very slim group—Christian Science, maybe certain late-nineteenth- or early-twentieth-century forms of Christianity—that wouldn’t go to modern science.
We could connect that to meaning. If your priest is also the person you go to when you get cancer, not just to help you pray and deal with impending loss but to maybe cure you, then the priest is more meaningful. The office of priesthood has more things in its title to which you ascribe meaning.
It could be a partial disenchantment. Most questions that might have gone to a religious leader are now engineering questions of one sort or another. We find the relevant experts. People come to my office because I know about psychology. They come for the one-on-one connection, and that’s a major part of what helps, but the expertise is part of it too. I think it’s at least a partial disenchantment.
Myron: It’s interesting that you mentioned nostalgia in the context of disenchantment and meaning. One strategy for boosting a person’s sense of meaning is to undertake practices that lean into their sense of nostalgia: write out their life story, or focus on periods from their past with a nostalgic gaze, so they’re reminded of being part of a life story that might be heading toward some sense of purpose. There’s an interesting connection between nostalgia and meaning.
Dan: Keith.
Audience member: Sarah, I think I heard you asking whether it’s possible for someone not to experience meaning while their life is still meaningful. That’s immediately relevant to my life these past few months, so it really clicked. But wouldn’t the existence of despair—and, to put an even finer point on it, suicide—prove that to be absolutely real?
Dan: Doesn’t the existence of suicidal ideation, which obviously happens all the time, show that—how would you phrase it?
Audience member: Doesn’t that immediately demonstrate the existence of it? [Unclear exchange.] People right now are telling me my life has meaning, and I just don’t believe that.
Dan: Does that not show that it’s possible to have a life that, by all accounts, appears meaningful, but you don’t experience it as meaningful, or maybe not meaningful enough?
Sarah: Or just not meaningful to you. You might have a very meaningful life to someone else. You matter to someone else. That’s true. We take that for granted. It’s obviously true that you could experience life as meaningless even though other people would experience your life as meaningful, for various reasons. That just doesn’t mean something for you. They might look at you and experience you as having a meaningful life.
If I’d had my way with this Meaning Making in the Modern World initiative we’ve all been doing, I probably would have called it “Meaning and Despair.” My partner works on hope and despair. You know what sells? Meaning and hope. You know what doesn’t sell? [Unclear] despair.
Matt: Give it time.
Sarah: In terms of the research, the shadow side of work on meaning and hope is despair. Both are equally hard to define. They’re both very much, “I know it when I feel it.” Or even better: “I know it when I’m in it.”
I’d love to see more sustained work on despair in a way that doesn’t get everybody freaked out that you’re sad. Let’s just talk about the experience and the absence of meaning and see what comes up.
Dan: You put the effort in to go sideways and get that hand up. That warrants it for you.
Audience member: I have a few questions that would derail the other ones, so I’ll have to choose one.
Dan: An existential quandary. Which one has meaning to you?
Audience member: My real question, and the reason I came to this session, is this: I am post-deconstruction, and I’ve really struggled with a felt need, or a felt lack of experience of awe, of experiencing the divine. Sarah, I know you’ve done work on that, and I’ve read some of your stuff too.
It’s very painful for me. How do I live? Some of me is looking for certainty. I’ve lost that certainty—sola scriptura, right? That’s completely gone. How do you see that felt, embodied experience and meaning making relating to each other?
Dan: How do we put the meaning-making conversation into conversation with the lived experience of what’s often on the other side of religious change: a real felt lack of transcendence, of connection with God? Am I getting that right?
Audience member: I think so. I’m sorry.
Dan: That’s okay.
Sarah: I’ll do one sentence. A lot of my work in the past was on divine hiddenness: the idea that no matter how much you desire to experience God in a way that’s salient, powerful, and meaningful for you, you just don’t. It’s a whole area of philosophy and theology.
Being very transparent and vulnerable, my work on that and my experiences with it were the biggest motivator for me in developing the meaning-making [wording unclear]. Meaning-making work exists well beyond me and anything I’m doing, but it’s a motivator.
For me, it’s less about certainty. You could have a very different experience, but the way I experienced and thought about it, it’s less about losing certainty in a particular set of doctrines. I don’t think I ever had certainty about anything theological. But I did experience a lot of the salient presence of something we could call God—a sense of being in right existence.
I don’t want to say “relationship”—it sounds so evangelical—but you’re positioned correctly metaphysically, and there’s something that makes everything okay, at least in my experience of life, without necessarily any theological claim attached to that.
Often, it’s not so much about certainty. It’s more about how you experience yourself in relation to the world and the possibility of the divine. We could have a conversation about what that looked like for me. I don’t want to take up more time, but I wouldn’t be doing the meaning-making stuff if I didn’t think it was relevant to divine hiddenness and the absence of divine connection.
Audience member: I have a philosophical belief in the existence of God, because I can’t conceive of a first cause otherwise. Who God is, how I relate to God, how I experience God, that I don’t know.
Dan: I’d want to normalize that. It’s a very hard and pretty common effect of losing that ironclad faith system. A lot of my clients experience it.
One concept that might be relevant: sometimes it’s helpful for clients to recognize that what they would really love is certainty that they’re in relationship with God. Maybe they can accept that they can’t get certainty that they are. But that’s not the same as not being able to get relationship with God. You may always be able to doubt it.
I do think the heroin metaphor is apt there. Certainty is a kind of drug—and it provides a lot of near-term benefits, but it has costs too. It’s a prolonged process to come to find the replacement package preferable to the original package. A lot of pain has to be felt, a lot of grief and acceptance work has to be done. Typically, it’s years long.
Audience member: I’m not concerned that I’m losing my mind. It just seems painful.
Dan: It’s painful.
Audience member: The less certainty I’ve had, I’m probably a nicer person to be around now.
Dan: The less certain you are, the nicer you are to be around. That’s an example of the hidden cost of a fundamentalist perspective: if you stray five percent out of the mold, then you’re a sinner. That’s not great for other people in your life.
I’ve even thought: Do we want a bunch of people who are happy, or a bunch whose lives are meaningful? Do we want to be around them? If everyone had really meaningful lives, I think that’s the community I’d want to be in. There’s a reciprocity between us.
Myron: I don’t know, man. “X is meaningful” is not the same as “X is good.” The people protesting yesterday, the Westboro Baptist people, have very meaningful lives.
Matt: I don’t think they’re happy, though, because they probably believe in eternal damnation.
Myron: They’re happy. They’re happy that we’re going there.
Matt: I think they’re afraid they’re going there. They’re not sure.
[Overlapping exchange.]
Matt: I want to talk about drugs.
Dan: 30 seconds.
Matt: Well, a minute. A drastic generalization: religious people think God’s up there somewhere, hidden. Spiritual people think God’s in here somewhere, hidden. I would say God might be something more like a social network.
We all hate social networks, but I mean in the broader sense of community—with other human beings, but also the stars at night. Get some good friends together, go camping in a place where you can see the night sky, and bring some psilocybin. And you will—
Dan: As a licensed clinician…
[Overlapping reactions.]
Matt: It’s safer than this [holds up beer], I will say.
Myron: When are we going to have Theology Mushroom Camp?
Dan: That’s called Burning Man.
We’ve got time for one more question, then we’re going to wrap it up. Bandana.
Audience member: This ties a couple of these questions together. You’ve spoken a lot about how religiosity correlates with meaning making. Increasingly, at least in my experience, there’s more overlap in my communities between progressive religious people and the “nones,” the spiritual but not religious. But we still have a fairly strong [wording unclear].
How do we build communities that take the lessons from religion and maintain a welcoming atmosphere for those outside traditional religious structures? How do we bring people together to make meaning without pushing away people who find religion confining?
Dan: The question is: We know that more conservative, traditional religions provide this meaning and structure. Your circles are like mine: if they’re religious, they’re progressive religious; otherwise they’re not religious, maybe spiritual or something like that. How do we take the best parts and leave the rest?
This is one of those hard trade-offs. There are better and worse ways to do it, but my current perspective is that the closed-groupness of conservative and traditional religion—the rigidity of the walls—produces a lot of the sense of belonging. It’s almost like a chemical reaction.
Matt: Oxytocin does this too. It binds you together with your loved ones and makes you protect them viciously, violently, from others.
Dan: Exactly. With oxytocin, if you’ve recently given birth and there’s somebody around you don’t feel safe around, you’re going to treat them very poorly.
Part of me wants to lean toward accepting that whatever we do—here’s what I’d say. If I had an ELCA or United Church of Christ pastor as a client who said, “I want so badly for my church to feel like the evangelical church I pastored. I’m the same pastor,” I’d work with him or her—it would have to be him, because her wouldn’t have been allowed to. I’d work with him on accepting that it probably isn’t going to happen.
There are consequences of that denominational shift. All things being equal, he should probably adjust his expectations and ask, “What are my best options?” instead of working himself to the bone to make something happen that’s unlikely to happen.
[Brief exchange about the gendered joke; wording unclear.]
Dan: I was just making a joke at the expense of evangelicals.
Myron: I really appreciate the question. One shorthand strategy is to compare the framework people have left—a framework that says, “I know these things to be true, and that means this, this, and this about you, the world, God, neighbor, and the planet”—and exchange that framework of certainty for one in which your community can articulate values and a sense of identity reflecting what you think is true.
Don’t shy away from articulating what you have to offer the world and people. Have a message of hope and good news that you’re not proclaiming you know is true, but that you still think is true and has value and meaning. That’s the space post-deconstruction spirituality and religious communities can lean into.
What we’ve seen in different iterations of this phenomenon is rightly rejecting toxic frameworks of certainty, but replacing them with a completely open hand for anything. A very ambiguous message about what you have to offer and why it matters doesn’t have the staying power.
Sarah: My recipe for what you could add to your group—because some of these things are very, very difficult—is that religion is really good at doing things we want it to do. Even if you don’t believe the stuff, you’re still going to want a similar sort of structure, tradition, or rituals in some ways if you want to get the goods of that relationship.
Constraint. A lot of it is constraint: theological, communal, social. You’re kind of forced to be with people, for reasons.
The other thing I feel doesn’t get enough airtime is transcendence. If you go to a Taylor Swift concert, something magical is happening there, and it’s going to be powerful for the group of friends who go together. Same with a football game. There’s something about this transcendence, being taken out of yourself and above yourself, that you don’t get if you’re in a vegan support group or something.
I’m fine looking at the mechanisms. How do we actually create communities that bring something to our lives, not just individually but as communities? It’s totally fine to get into the technical details of that.
Dan: Thank you guys so much for coming. We had excellent questions. I’ll hang around a little longer, and I’m sure they will too if they can. We can answer more questions one-on-one.










